Will “disruptive innovation” prophet Cathie Wood’s flock need an “ARK?”

Mickey Kim / September 3, 2021

Whether it’s Ali vs. Frazier in boxing (the “Thrilla in Manila”), Duke vs. Kentucky in basketball or Godzilla vs. Kong in the movies, when “titans” clash, it always makes for great theatre.

A similar brouhaha recently unfolded in the investment world.  In one corner is Cathie Wood, portfolio manager for the ARK Innovation exchange-traded fund (Nasdaq—ARKK), who was in the right place at the right time and rode the wave of populist sentiment of “disruptive innovation” that resonated with the army of new thrill-seeking investors born in the depths of the pandemic to fame and fortune.

ARK Innovation was up a stunning 147.8% in 2020 (vs. the S&P 500 total return of 18.4%), which led to Wood’s assets under management surging from less than $10 billion at the end of 2019 to almost $85 billion today.

Wood is an “ideas-driven, big picture” investor, known affectionately as “Mamma Cathie” or “Aunt Cathie” to her legion of followers.  According to ARKK’s Prospectus, “’disruptive innovation’ is the introduction to a technologically enabled new product or service that potentially changes the way the world works.”  Additionally, while we’re big believers in “eating our own cooking,” officers and Trustees of ARKK own a paltry 0.1% of the shares.

For Wood, it’s all about the technology, future growth prospects and momentum, not current profitability or stock valuation.

In the other corner is Michael Burry, who earned his fame (as subject of the book and movie, “The Big Short”) and fortune betting against the bubble in the U.S. housing market and related subprime mortgage bonds in 2007, the bursting of which precipitated the worst global financial crisis since the Great Depression.

Unlike Wood, Burry is data-driven and all about fundamentals like profitability and valuation.

In regulatory filings on August 16, Burry’s Scion Asset Management, along with several other hedge funds, reported making bearish, negative bets on Wood’s ARKK.  Adding insult to injury, plans were revealed for the Short ARKK (SARK) exchange traded fund, designed to deliver the daily inverse performance of ARKK.

ARKK’s naysayers argue 1) the stocks it owns are wildly overvalued and 2) many of the companies owned are expected to lose money for the foreseeable future and are thus dependent on a continuous, abundant supply of ultra-low-cost funding, which will end when (not if) the Fed begins raising interest rates.

Wood fired back, “To his credit, Michael Burry made a great call based on fundamentals and recognized the calamity brewing in the housing/mortgage market.  I do not believe that he understands the fundamentals that are creating explosive growth and investment opportunities in the innovation space.”

Warren Buffett famously said, “Price is what you pay.  Value is what you get.”  In that spirit, let’s do a quick valuation exercise comparing ARKK’s ten largest (out of 50) holdings versus the “FAANG” stocks, mega-capitalization technology stocks that have done spectacularly well and driven S&P 500 performance for the past too many years.

Price/Earnings Price/Sales % Change (2020) % Change (2021)
ARK Innovation (10 Largest)
Tesla (10.6% of ARKK) 133.7 16.1 743.4% 0.9%
Teladoc Health (5.6%) Loss 11.4 138.8% -28.6%
Roku (5.3%) 288.0 19.9 148.0% 7.5%
Coinbase Global (4.8%) 44.8 37.2 NM 3.7%
Unity Software (4.6%) Loss 31.5 195.1% -19.5%
Zoom Video (4.5%) 73.3 29.9 395.8% 1.0%
Square (4.3%) 147.1 7.7 247.9% 23.1%
Shopify (4.2%) 234.1 47.5 184.7% 35.3%
Twilio (3.6%) Loss 25.1 244.4% 6.7%
Spotify (3.3%) Loss 4.2 110.4% -28.2%
“FAANG” Stocks
Facebook 22.6 9.9 33.1% 36.4%
Apple 27.0 7.3 80.7% 12.5%
Amazon 48.1 3.7 76.3% 2.8%
Netflix 50.5 8.9 67.1% 3.4%
Alphabet (Google) 26.4 8.6 30.9% 64.3%

Source: Bloomberg as of 8/27/2021

A couple things stand out.  First, four of ARKK’s ten largest holdings lose money.  Second, based on both Price-to-Earnings and Price-to-Sales valuation metrics, ARKK’s ten largest have astronomical valuations.  Third, looking at 2020 and 2021 performance, you can see why ARKK was up 147.8% vs. 18.4% for the S&P 500 in 2020, but down 2% through August 27, vs. up 21.2% for the S&P 500.  As Tesla goes, so goes ARKK.

Burry warned of a coming flood of biblical proportions.  “All hype/speculation is doing is drawing in retail (investors) before the mother of all crashes,” he warned.  Further, “#FOMO Parabolas don’t resolve sideways:  When crypto falls from trillions, or meme stocks fall from tens of billions, #MainStreet losses will approach the size of countries.  History ain’t changed.”

The opinions expressed in these articles are those of the author as of the date the article was published. These opinions have not been updated or supplemented and may not reflect the author’s views today. The information provided in these articles does not provide information reasonably sufficient upon which to base an investment decision and should not be considered a recommendation to purchase or sell any particular stock or other investment.


Subscribe to stay up to date with the latest news, articles and newsletters from Kirr Marbach.